« John Rogers, mensch | Main | Reading »

January 26, 2008


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Will Baird

Very kewl, Carlos. Not the one I was hoping for - cyad being poisonous to mammals and its implications - but even so this is damned kewl. I didn't know about anything about trehalose at all. I like the hypothesis about when it might have arisen and why. is there anything testable about it? y'know to try to verify it?


1) I've never heard of the Bloch book. Should I have?

2) I knew about trehalose in general terms, via the route you'd expect: Hibernating insects are a major food source for overwintering birds. That sounds simple and obvious, but it plays out in some really complicated ways.

Are insects really the only animal lineage that synthesizes trehalose? Because there are others that could make use of it.

3) Question: If trehalose is more stable than glucose, what's the downside? You might expect to see it in more lineages, doing more stuff. Is it too stable, or hard to synthesize? Toxic?

Doug M.


Thanks, Will! Wasn't sure which one you wanted, and the cycad toxicity one completely slipped my mind.

Trehalose synthesis in insects uses a specific enzyme (trehalose-6-phosphate synthase, a rather uninformative enzyme name) which is of course coded for in the DNA. Comparative genetic studies could probably say something interesting about it.

The synthesis uses glucose-6-phosphate -- phosphate is used in carbohydrate metabolism to activate a compound -- and uracil-diphosphate-glucose. It's the same uracil that's in RNA. When you have an RNA base attached to something, it's a strong sign that it's not only activated, but metabolically partitioned. The most common one is adenine: e.g., adenine triphosphate (ATP), ubiquitous in metabolism. Uracil compounds are comparatively rare.

Doug, it's slightly energetically expensive to produce trehalose from two glucose molecules, and it's slightly energetically expensive to break it down to glucose again. So there is a disadvantage.

Also, compared to glucose, trehalose doesn't have any convenient chemical hooks. It's a little like the difference between diesel and gasoline. In fact, glucose would show toxicity at some concentrations where trehalose is found.

But most probably, the synthetic reaction is somewhat difficult to reach in enzyme space. To use the jargon, it's a 1,1 linkage between glucose molecules. Most of the really common biological ones are 1,4 -- cellulose, glycogen, starch -- with starch having a few 1,6 branches.

Trehalose is found in some other invertebrate lineages, like the tardigrades, and in (of course) fungi. But it's not found in many organisms where one might expect it. And in vertebrates, not at all.

There aren't many popular books on classical biochemistry. Bloch's is one.

Doug M.

"it's slightly energetically expensive to produce trehalose from two glucose molecules, and it's slightly energetically expensive to break it down to glucose again. So there is a disadvantage."

That makes sense. However, googling brings up this:

"Trehalose is the major carbohydrate energy storage molecule used by insects for flight. One possible reason for this is that the double glycosidic linkage of trehalose, when acted upon by an insect trehalase, releases two molecules of glucose, which is required for the rapid energy requirements of flight. This is double the efficiency of glucose release from the storage polymer starch, for which cleavage of one glycosidic linkage releases only one glucose molecule."

Huh. If that's right, it's a really fascinating example of preadaptation (and yes, I like that term just fine).

"Insect trehalase" -- apparently we vertebrates have our own trehalase, which is why we can eat things that contain trehalose: insects. And mushrooms, if we're so inclined. I wonder if trehalase is lost in vertebrate lineages that never encounter trehalose; obligate carnivores, say, or toothy cetaceans.

Apparently it's also being investigated as a treatment for Huntingtons; trehalose impedes certain types of protein accumulation, and that's exactly what causes Huntington's.

(How did we live before google? How??)

Doug M.


Um. That's true, but somewhat off-point. Consider: what disaccharide doesn't produce two monosaccharides on cleavage? I mean, it's definitional. Sucrose, maltose, lactose. And starch wouldn't be the comparandum in animals; glycogen would be.

Anyhow, in insects, the trehalose precursors are formed from the breakdown of glycogen. Any sugars in the diet first have to be incorporated into glycogen storage, via the insect's fat body organ -- roughly equivalent to the vertebrate liver -- and then released for trehalose formation. So it's not obviously a quick release mechanism.

Little is known about insect trehelAse regulation, how the enzymes which break down trehalose into glucose are controlled. The mammalian trehalases, incidentally, are on the villi of the small intestine and in the kidney, and appear to be unregulated. Pure digestion.

Noel Maurer

Doug: fairly easily.

Maybe if they get around to finishing that Google Book thing, then that will change. But right now, well, the internets don't provide all that much more useful knowledge (or even, more surprisingly, data) than what you already have in a good office library.

Of course, this doesn't apply if you are polymathic way beyond the norm.

Which you are. But I'm not, and neither, sadly, are most people. So it's nice, and I miss being able to immediately pull up sports records and the like, but I'm loth to exaggerate.

Of course, I'd never have learned about insects' nature antifreeze in the pre-Internets day.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)